Saturday, June 28, 2008

Ask The Marshmallow: Sick? Eat something.

Thank you all for your kind comments on the race - now it's been almost a week since the race, funnily enough, I don't really remember the running. I do, however, remember the rain! In fact, my shoes are STILL drying out(!).

Now, the next lot of posts will be my responses to your queries in the 'Ask the Marshmallow Anything' series. The first question is from Premee.

I'm a brown girl living in Canada, born to crazy immigrant parents, and I would love to hear more about your crazy brown parents and their quirks regarding self-made ideas of 'health' and 'weight.' For instance, whenever my brother or I got sick as a child, my mom would always ask, "Are you sure you're sick? Why don't you eat something."

It's been very interesting observing the behaviour with my Mum regarding the self-made ideas of health and weight. Since I'm the female out of the two children, my role was obviously to be pretty, and snatch a man - or a son in law. Being 'overweight' from a very young age, I was constantly told that I wouldn't be loved if I were fat.

Though one thing I definitely noticed was that when I was sick, my Mum would let me eat food. In fact, she would make my favourite foods. I almost enjoyed being sick because of the comfort that my favourite foods would bring with me. And now that I think about it, most of the foods weren't even junk food. They were hearty stews, fish curry, roasted chicken - and even simple pleasures that I couldn't normally have like toast with jam.

I know for a fact that I have very little knowledge of the concept of 'hunger'. This stems right back to when I was a baby - hospitalised at 3 weeks old for a vicious combination of pnuemonia and bronchitis, underweight. Because I was underweight, my parents force-fed me my bottle milk. When I rejected the milk, my Mum would pretty much shove the bottle teat into my mouth and pour the milk down my throat so that I drank all of the milk in the bottle.

It sounds torturous - but it's because I was a sick baby, and she was applying her self-made idea of health to me. As a result, I've almost completely lost my sense of hunger and 'fullness' that babies are born with. The thing is, I was sick because of a respiratory issue. Nothing to do with my weight or food intake. I was an underweight baby, but I was not underweight as a result of the illness. The force-feeding was my Mum's attempt at trying to make me 'un-sick'.

Fast forward eight years, where I had to go through traumatic, invasive eye surgery, and was stuck at home, by myself, for weeks on end. Because the surgery was on my eyes, I couldn't watch TV, I couldn't read books, I couldn't do colouring-in books, I couldn't play Lego, I couldn't go outside - I couldn't do jack-shit. My Mum's work wasn't far from home, so she would come home and make a nice lunch for me, always making me far more than I needed because I was recovering from the surgery. The food felt healing, and comforting, and I'm fairly certain that my exposure to comfort eating began because my Mum used food as a comfort for me when I was unwell or injured. And I kept eating even when I probably had had enough because I had lost my innate ability to distinguish when I had eaten enough, though the food continued to come because of the surgical wounds.

My brother - on the other hand - was overdue when he was born. He was a larger baby, and my parents didn't force-feed him when he was on the bottle. Even if he had two sips of milk and rejected the bottle, they didn't try to force it down him. As a result, he knows when he's done.

My Mum feels much more frustrated with him when he refuses food when he's sick. She pretty much begs him to eat when he's sick, but he doesn't budge. Even recently he's been sick and he doesn't want to eat food when my Mum pushes it on him, he'll just shrink away upstairs and get into bed. Meanwhile, my Mum is jumping up and down and tearing her hair out - as if not feeding him has taken away her ability to comfort him and make him feel better.

I know that in Indian culture, physical contact isn't really encouraged. What my Mum probably didn't realise when I was unwell was that I enjoyed it when she had to put her hand to my forehead to feel if I had a fever. It felt comforting, and possibly moreso than any food that she could've made for me. Sometimes, I would even say to my Mum, "I think I have a fever, can you feel my forehead?" She would touch my forehead and tell me off for trying to fool her into getting a day off school, but that's not what it was about.

I don't think my family know how to hug, how to pat you on the back or shoulder or on the head - and one thing that I have *always* been fascinated by is this concept of 'kissing it better'. That's something I haven't been exposed to in my own family, and whenever I watch the kids on TV getting scrapes and bruises, the 'kissing it better' intrigued me, and on a bad day, made me reeeeeeeeeeal jealous.

When we were sick was the only, solitary time where it didn't matter that we were fat, dark skinned, or whatever. We were allowed to eat, encouraged to eat.

It's a big insult to refuse food in an Indian household - and I know this whenever I go to see my grandparents.

Every Friday I go and buy some wholemeal and walnut bread for my grandmother, and after Body Balance, I drop it off to them. They ask me if I want to have some dinner, and I politely decline them. They always become cold, grumpy, and irritable - like I've slapped them in the face with a banana skin.

Whenever we've been sick, injured, or whatnot, our relatives come over not with flowers, but with food. When I was in hospital after my several surgeries, I didn't get flowers or soft toys. I got food.

In Bollywood movies, I constantly see a distinction to the characters who are 'authentic, traditional Indians' to the 'Non-resident Indians'; being the ones who have made other countries their home, like the United Kingdom, USA, Australia, South Africa, Kenya, and New Zealand. The Indians poke fun at the Non-Resident Indians for declining a third or fourth aloo paratha, or deciding to go out for a run.

The physical connectiveness thing is noted as well - and I can 'somewhat' quote a scene from Mujhse Dosti Karoge. (Please note that I'm going by memory, translated into English from the Indian dialogue, so the words may not be 100% accurate. That and I cannot be bothered going downstairs to sift through my mother's extensive bollywood DVD collection to quote it exactly.)

Non Resident Indian BoyThese bangles belong to my mother*. When she sees you wearing them, she'll understand. That meeeeeeeans... *leans in for a kiss*
Indian GirlNoooooooo, after the wedding *gently pushes the boy away*
Non Resident Indian Boy*exasperated* Man, this is the problem with Indian girls. EVERYTHING is 'after the wedding'
* Indian Girl laughs and shakes her head in a 'you wouldn't understand' manner.


*- I think...

When I'm not sick, I'm constantly told that I need to lose weight. Never for my health though, it was always for my appearance. It was never about how I'm going to die young, but rather, about how I was going to die lonely, and unhappy. I *had* to be thin and attractive if I wanted to catch a man, and to attain affection. For a long time, I believed them. And like scenes in the movie that I've mentioned above, I believed that EVERYTHING happens after the wedding. Life begins after you're married. And I wouldn't get married if I was fat, because noone wants to marry a fatty.

One thing that I've had to learn is that my family regard health and weight as two completely different concepts. Weight is a stain on your physical appearance which flaws your fundamental purpose - to snag a man and be makin' bebbies - while health? When it's under threat, food solves all.

I have issues with both of these notions. And sometimes I am made to wonder as to whether it's a personality clash, or whether it's a cultural barrier that is much bigger than myself and my family.

After all. I remember very clearly the mother in My Big Fat Greek Wedding throwing her hands up in the air and saying, "Eat something!", as though the food would magically sway her away from marrying a Non-Greek.


Seems as though it ain't just Indians!
Uh... so I've babbled on a bit. I hope that was what were after, Premee! I'll answer the second part of your question in another post.

Until next time, you lovely people!

10 comments:

Kek said...

Gah! Parents! You know, my in-laws are the non-kissing, non-hugging type. There is/was never any physical affection shown in that house, and don't get me started on the verbal put-downs my husband was subjected to as a kid. He doesn't have food issues, but he DOES have a lot of emotional 'junk' that he really needs to work through.

MY family...anything was an excuse for a hug or a kiss. Coming home, going out, going to bed, bumping your kneem, getting a Brownie badge. Or no reason at all.

Here's the funny thng though - MY mother did the show your love via food thing. HIS mother didn't. Well, she may have tried, but she's a crap cook, so it would never have worked anyway. LOL.

I'm not screwed up - no more than most anyway - but I do struggle with emotional eating. He can look at food and walk on by, no matter how he's feeling. But, boy! Does he ever have some weird shit going on in his head.

My point? Uh... parents have such an impact on their kids mental wellbeing that it scares me sometimes. How are my boys going to turn out? So far, so good...

Premee said...

Yay, thanks! It's so reassuring to hear that my parents aren't the only one with The Crazy. Growing up it was all "Only fair-skinned girls will find husbands, so stay out of the sun!" I actually bought a SOMBRERO a couple of years ago at my mother's request so I could stop getting so 'dark.' The lack of touching is the same in my family, no hugging or hand-holding even as kids, even in family photos. And the food thing!

Just today, my dad was heard to say "Here, finish this up, I don't want it sitting in the fridge." When I turned down a second poori, he snorted and said, "Oh, that won't help your weight." He went grocery shopping and plunked a bar of Cadbury's in front of me: "Here, I bought you some chocolate." My mom just said "I made you a cup of tea, but I put Splenda in it because you're getting kind of fat, don't you think?" Last night it was "You'd probably have a husband by now if you lost some weight" AND "We want you to find a boy who loves you for your mind." :-S
Your parents sound just like mine!!

Art said...

Top notch post.

I personally firmly believe in the healing powers of food. I believe that when I am sick, extra calories are needed for the fight my body is going through. It seems to be true for me at least, because I don't gain weight at these times.

My parents never really encouraged me, but they never really stopped me from eating, either.

Again, great post.

Fat Lazy Guy said...

Great post :)

Man, in my family, we never really did the "healing with food" thing, but that's probably because I was allowed to eat whatever I wanted anyway.

I don't know where I picked it up, probably from t.v., but I'm definitely a "show love with food" type person. Whenever my mates come around, I always make sure to cook them something nice, or if they have a request I make it for them the next time they come round.

aishchai said...

You have just described my Jewish family. "Nu? Eat already? What's the matter? You got a fever- have some chicken soup. Makes you feel better...."

Art said...

Another note: My family, being very American, is pretty physical. A lot of hugging and whatnot. I am a major hugger. I like human contact. Except that it makes me hot.

boobsihazthem said...

Big Fat Greek Wedding is one of those films that I have to see one day, but I always get bored during the first hour or so.

Oh well. Great analysis. For me and my mother, I always saw my mother snacking. She always snacked - but not on unhealthy foods. I ended up doing the same from a young age, and gained weight very quickly, as it was combined with a relatively inactive lifestyle. A part of me thinks I would have been thinner if I had had a younger sibling to play with/compete with.

My mum just dowsed me with tea when I was ill. And Ice Cream, and Toast. And that was about it!

cmae said...

I'm reaching out across the miles and giving you a huge, warm, affectionate hug!

( . )( . ) said...

Its amazing how the little things our parents do can warp our association to food.

I am now a big believer of only eating when I am actually physically hungry. It took me a long time to realise that there is no need to eat at some pre scheduled time, just because society tells us its normal to have 3 meals. If my body is hungry it will tell me it needs to eat. I can go 6-8 hours without eating and still feel great.

Its been the only way I have been able to lose weight after so many years of trying. And its so simple. I eat whatever the hell I want, but only when im actually hungry!!

That got a bit off the parents topic didnt it, but it relates to the fact that my parents instilled the eat your entire plate, eat this, eat that rule, when i should NEVER have been eating, if I didnt need the food!!

Marshmallow said...

Kek - Yeah parents have quite an impact on the way that kids turn out, so much that it has quite possibly freaked me out of ever having kids! You, though, seemed to have done well with your lot :-D

Premee - You're welcome, thank you for asking the question! It's always nice to know that someone else is experiencing the same thing as you, even when things seem to illogical to make sense, as per your Dad with the Cadbury and your Mum with the Splenda!

Art - I do think that food has a healing power, yes, though I think the healing power and the comforting aspect of food often get confused. Great point, though - when your body is depleted by an illness, when you don't feel like eating, is when you need the food the most. And as for human contact making you hot, Ahahaha! :-D

Fat Lazy Guy - I certainly noticed that, especially with the brittle and cookies that you sent me! (I'll... assume thats... err... 'love'?) I know that iv'e taken the same sort of thing from my parents; I like to entertain by making food, BUT, I do like encouraging people to join me for Body Jam or RPM. I'm getting there!

aishchai - Heck, it sounds like a rather universal phenomena! We're all the same but different.

boobsihazthem - Yeah, the beginning of that is really to set the scene. As with any culturally based film - Bend it Like Beckham was the same. While you picked up the snacking habit from witnessing your Mum, did she exercise? I know if I had witnessed my Mum exercising, I perhaps wouldn't have taken 20 years to get into the exercise habit!

cmae - Thank you :-D

Arna - It sounds like you're doing great :-D I've made the switch to intuitive eating as well, though I do know there is still some emotional damage that I need to resolve, and that involves looking back over why I got to an unhealthy state in the first place. You, though? Sound pretty awesome. :-)

Post a Comment